June 01, 2009

Channeling the tech-challenged user

An IT tale about a tech support call, a missing Palm, and a reminder to rethink basic assumptions

I read about a tech support incident similar to this but thought it was a joke -- until it happened to me.

I was on call one weekend, praying the phone would not ring. My wife and I were out for a pleasant ride in the country when my cell phone went off.

[ Want to cash in on your IT experiences? Send your amazing IT tale, lesson learned the hard way, or war story from the trenches to offtherecord@infoworld.com. If we publish it, we'll send you a $50 American Express gift card. ]

The caller was a senior staff member who went to the office to do some work on the weekend. She was not technically inclined and tended to get quite impatient with technology -- and we tended to cringe when she called. She was terribly upset because her Palm was missing. It took me a few questions to discern exactly what this meant: The icon for her Palm Pilot was always on her monitor, but today she couldn't find it.

Thus began the next phase of the diagnostic.

Did she open My Computer and look for it there? No, she couldn't "find her computer." (What?)

Did she try rebooting? Yes, but she still couldn't find her Palm.

It wasn't on her desktop? No.

What was on her desktop? Nothing.

The Q&A continued for about 15 minutes. (This was before Bluetooth, so I had pulled over to the side of the road to think better.) What was I missing?

Finally, she mentioned that her cursor had also disappeared. When? Apparently, she hadn't seen it at all during our conversation.

Could she open the CD tray? Nope.

A ha!

Could she try a different plug for her computer? She crawled under her desk and swapped outlets but nothing happened. Then she remembered that her desk light wouldn't come on.

After half an hour on the phone, we had gotten to the root of the problem: The outlets on one wall were out. A circuit breaker must have blown. She got an extension cord, was back in business, and could finally see her Palm icon.

This incident reminds me of a couple of basic "rules" to live by when working with end-users. First, listen and know the person, if possible. We were heading in a wrong direction with the problem solution until I tried to put myself in her position, visualize her situation, and think like her. Second, don't take anything for granted. Check the basics without insulting the person. What may be obvious to tech support may not be obvious to the end-user. I would have noticed right away that the monitor didn't have power, but she didn't.

White Paper

D2D Virtual Tape Library Replication Primer

This whitepaper explains the terminology and concepts behind Data Replication technologies and establishes some sizing rules through worked examples. Learn the new paradigm in disaster tolerance—protect data anywhere.

Download now »

White Paper

An Alternative to Virtualization for Datacenter Cost Savings

Server virtualization is a popular option for dealing with mounting datacenter costs. Another equally promising approach is the use of an Application Delivery Controller. Citrix NetScaler provides a low-cost way for organizations to reduce their server count and accrue cost savings from a reduction in space, cooling, power and personnel.

Download now »

White Paper

Why Your Firewall, VPN, and IEEE 802.11i Aren't Enough to Protect Your Network

The emergence of WLANs has created a new breed of security threats to enterprise networks.

Included in HP ProCurve WLAN solutions is security technology that alleviates threats from WLANs through:
* Monitoring wireless activity inside and out of the enterprise
* Classifying WLAN transmissions into harmful and harmless
* Preventing transmissions that pose a security threat to the enterprise network
* Locating participating devices for physical remediation

Download now »

White Paper

Bringing the Edge to the Data Center

Effectively address data protection challenges, implementing solutions that help store and protect business–critical data while cutting costs and improving efficiency and reliability.

Download now »
Accounting IT Guy 1-Jun-09 8:15am
1 reply
Is it really so wrong to "assume" that end user can tell the difference between on and off? I mean..... would you sit in your car and proceed to call the mechanic and tell him that your key doesnt work? Sit down on the couch and tell the cable company that your "Lifetime channel" is gone? In this day and age with the amount of electrical devices that are in everybodys home, I would freakin hope we've all mastered the On/Off aspect of technology. I guess not...
rcprimak 1-Jun-09 9:00pm
2 replies

Accounting IT Guy --

I think you missed an important point: This woman, who is not tech savvy, had plugged in and turned on the monitor and the computer. What she failed to recognize was that nothing on the desktop was showing up. A very easy thing for us tech-savvy folks to notice, but not so easy for a true technophobe.

As the author implies, sometimes you have to put yourself inside the heads of those who know absolutely nothing about computers -- or wall outlets and breakers, for that matter!

And the concept of one wall being "live" while another nearby wall is "dead" can elude even IT Pros once in awhile. I've seen it happen!

Loerps 2-Jun-09 7:17am
Well said. Sometimes the hardest part is asking the right questions without denting their self esteem. End users can get defensive very quickly.
Accounting IT Guy 2-Jun-09 9:51am
2 replies
Who says you have to be a technical worker to know what on and off is? Compputers work like all the other crap I bet this lady has in her house... tv, dvr, hairdryer, hair iron, radio, etc, etc, etc. Everyone that lives in the modern world should be able to figure out power issues. The problem is that lazy people get catered to... not that troubleshooting power issues is too complex. It's not hard to determine if the device has failed or if the socket is not live. This goes way beyond IT too...
Regaug 2-Jun-09 1:12pm
1 reply
As an in-the-trenches IT veteran, I agree with "Accounting IT Guy", at least in principle. At some point, people have to take some responsibility for themselves on the tools they want to use in life. "rcprimak" states that the user had "plugged in and turned on the monitor", but failed to notice that it wasn't working. I think that's no different than getting into your car, turning the key, and failing to notice that the engine doesn't start. Is it really smart, from society's point of view, to coddle people into becoming so "insulated" from technical reality?
rcprimak 3-Jun-09 5:04pm
1 reply

Some people are not so much "insulated" as just too busy to learn in detail how their work tools operate. Remember, tech (computers, monitors, printers, even breaker panels) is just a collection or work tools. People want things like these to "just work" so they can get on with their real jobs.

Hiram Q. Pustule 24-Jun-09 9:31am
"Some people are not so much 'insulated' as just too busy to learn in detail how their work tools operate." Not only is that not an acceptable excuse, it actually underscores the user's unsuitability for employment in that position. If you need to use a tool to get your job done, you have a responsibility to your employer and to those who depend on your work product to know how to use your tools. If you don't know how a deep fryer operates, you have no business using one professionally. If you don't know how to use a food slicer, you should not be using one on the job. And if you don't know how to tell whether a monitor is on or off, you are incompetent for a job that requires the use of a computer as a tool.
rcprimak 3-Jun-09 4:58pm

The power issues are more complicated where there are breakers invovled. A lot of people think that if one outlet in a room is working, then all outlets in that room should be working. It does sometimes require a bit of explaining to get people to realize that different outlets, even close to one another, can be on different breakers. That is not intuitively obvious to anyone, even some techies.

CodeZombie 2-Jun-09 8:27am
1 reply
This reminds of the old WordPerfect tech support story where it turned out the user was in an office where the power had gone out and the tech told the user to take all the equipment back to the store because the user was too f'in' stupid to use a computer. I don't think it ever really happened. Nor do I believe the one about the guy who tried to use the CD-ROM tray as a coffee cup holder. And I'm very tempted to say that this story is just an update of the WordPerfect tech support story. Nice spin but I don't buy it. The user would notice that there's absolutely nothing on the screen! Even one of my ex-wife's former boyfriends wasn't that stupid and he didn't have the common sense that God gave gravel.
rcprimak 3-Jun-09 5:00pm
1 reply

The CD ROM being used as a cupholder did happen a few years, when CD ROMs and CD players were much less common than they are today. And WordPerfect did not have the greatest tech support in those days. Both stories are true.

CodeZombie 5-Jun-09 11:32pm
1 reply
According to snopes.com both stories are myths.
CD-ROM cup holder (scroll down to the bottom of the page):
http://www.snopes.com/autos/techno/choke.asp
WordPerfect Tech Support story:
http://www.snopes.com/humor/business/wordperfect.asp
If you've got proof to the contrary, please post it.
CodeZombie 5-Jun-09 11:47pm
1 reply
Okay, I just read further down the page on the WordPerfect Tech Support story and it turns out that there is some truth to it. The true part ends shortly after the tech discovers that the user is trying to access the computer during a power outage. So, I guess I've got to give you the WordPerfect story but snopes still lists the cup holder story as being a myth.
rcprimak 8-Jun-09 8:17am
One for two -- beats my usual track record when thinking off the top of my head. Yeah, I should have gone to my Snopes bookmark before posting.
De_safran 2-Jun-09 8:58am
This story reminds me of a tech support question I got for a TV. It was not plugged in. One should first determine if the problem is hardware or software and if the problem is local to a single computer or all the computers in an area. If the problem really was with the circuit breaker, there is a bigger problem with electricity supply that must be solved. If someone in the office was operating a toaster on the same circuit as the computer, the toaster must be removed. The extension cord may have solved the immediate problem, but it didn't solve the whole problem.
jvande7471 2-Jun-09 10:01am
1 reply
I work at a medium sized manufacturing site for a large corporation. One day one of our transformers exploded, causing a small fire and knocking out power to the plant completely. After the plant was evacuated, and the power company and fire department cleared the building as safe, everyone in IT charged in with flashlights to disconnect all computer equipment. We didn't know what would happen when the new transformer was engaged, and didn't want to wipe out all our computers with a massive power surge. After just a few days, the new transformer was in place and people were allowed to return to work. The general manager called IT because he couldn't get his computer to come back up. When told he needed to plug everything back in, he said that he already had but it still wasn't working. A tech was dispatched immediately to go take care of the issue. Turns out he had plugged his power strip back into itself. That was the first open socket he saw.
CodeZombie 2-Jun-09 7:41pm
That I can believe. If the wall outlets are behind a desk and the power strip has the only visible open outlets a user could easily do that.
tommomatic 2-Jun-09 7:59pm
What color is the light on the monitor/is there a light on the monitor/was there one before....? The absolute first question(in this instance) if you have no history with the caller...I usually have worked supporting state workers. Some are 'ept, while others...(have their supervisor calling form a different PC in usually another location)....need some 'coddle-ling'.
LabRat 14-Jul-09 8:53am
I do tech support for phone systems, legacy and VoIP. We use the "Please pack the phone back up in it's original box and return it because you're to stupid to use it" AFTER we get off the phone with the user. We would never tell them that - but we say it after the fact to each other all the time to indicate our frustration to that call. Also, "is it plugged in?" is usually our first question to users who scream dead power. My peeves are "It doesn't work" or "It's broken" or "It's bad" - OK - well - what EXACTLY is wrong with it?????

Sign up to receive InfoWorld Resource Alerts

Subscribe to the Off the Record Newsletter

The one-stop resource center for IT professionals.

©1994-2009 Infoworld, Inc.